Britain’s national broadcaster has temporarily halted two diversity training programmes focused on transgender and LGBT issues whilst reviewing their compliance with a landmark Supreme Court ruling that redefined how “sex” is interpreted under equality legislation.
The BBC confirmed it has paused its LGBTQ+ Allies programme and Trans Insights training sessions pending final government guidance following the court’s April decision. The ruling determined that “sex” within the Equality Act 2010 refers explicitly to biological sex assigned at birth, rather than self-identified gender, even for individuals holding a Gender Recognition Certificate.
Documents obtained through a freedom of information request by The Telegraph revealed that four training courses within the broadcaster’s 2024 diversity strategy contained references to sex and gender that required assessment following the legal clarification.
Two additional programmes, the BBC and You course and Inclusive Leadership training, have undergone modifications rather than full suspension. Changes include the removal of content on pronouns and material relating to gender self-identification, ensuring alignment with the Supreme Court’s interpretation of sex-based protections under equality law.
Legal Clarification Prompts Review
The Supreme Court’s unanimous ruling in For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers came after a five-year legal battle concerning the definition of women on public boards in Scotland. The court concluded that the terms “man”, “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex, not certificated sex obtained through gender recognition.
Lord Hodge, delivering the court’s opinion, cautioned against reading the judgement as a triumph of one group over another, emphasising that transgender people retain protection from discrimination under the gender reassignment characteristic within the Equality Act.
A BBC spokesman emphasised the broadcaster’s continued commitment to inclusion. “We are not rowing back on our inclusivity training – we have simply paused two of our courses while we await final guidance from the Government following the Supreme Court ruling,” the spokesperson stated.
“Once we have this, we’ll ensure our training and the language it uses are updated to meet any legal obligations. We have assessed where ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ are referred to across HR policies and training and we identified four training courses where there are references to ‘sex’ and ‘gender’. We have implemented changes as a result.”
The broadcaster added that it fully intends to comply with the law once guidance has been approved by Government, whilst ensuring it provides facilities that respect the needs and rights of all staff and visitors.
Concerns Over Workplace Culture
Susan Smith, co-director of For Women Scotland, the campaign group that successfully challenged the Scottish Government’s interpretation of equality legislation, expressed concerns about the implications for BBC employees who acknowledge biological sex differences.
Speaking to The Telegraph, Ms Smith suggested the training programmes could create difficulties for what she termed “sex-realist staff” within the corporation. For some time, insiders and licence-fee payers have been concerned about the level of capture which gender identity ideology has achieved in the purportedly unbiased BBC,” she said.
Ms Smith questioned whether the corporation offered similar “allies” training for other protected characteristics under equality law. “Our only surprise is that there were just four courses which gave rise to concerns; we also wonder if the corporation offered training for ‘allies’ on any other protected characteristic,” she added.
She urged the BBC to “come clean about the extent of this training and move urgently to ensure that staff are apprised of the realities of the law so that they can adhere to the Supreme Court ruling and ensure better, fairer reporting on this subject.”
Broader Implications for Organisations
The Equality and Human Rights Commission, Britain’s equality regulator, has been working to produce updated statutory guidance following the Supreme Court ruling. The commission published an interim update in April, noting the judgement has implications for workplaces, services open to the public, sporting bodies, schools and associations across the country.
Baroness Kishwer Falkner, chairwoman of the EHRC, welcomed the clarity the ruling brought, stating the importance “to those whose rights are affected under the Equality Act cannot be overstated.”
The commission emphasised that whilst the ruling clarifies the definition of sex in the Equality Act, transgender people continue to be protected from discrimination and harassment through the protected characteristic of gender reassignment.
Diversity Strategy Commitments
The suspension of training courses comes despite commitments outlined in the BBC’s 2024 diversity strategy, which stated the broadcaster remained committed to ensuring LGBT+ staff “feel a sense of belonging at the BBC.”
The strategy acknowledged: “We are proud of the progress that has been made, but we know we have more to do to ensure we truly represent the audiences we serve, particularly in the areas of ethnicity and disability.”
It recognised that workforce groupings used to set diversity goals “may not represent the way in which everyone chooses to describe themselves” but maintained these categories were “important to hold ourselves to account, report on our progress and ensure we’re focused on dismantling the barriers that are experienced by people from different backgrounds.”
The BBC previously withdrew from Stonewall’s Diversity Champions Programme in November 2021 following concerns about perceived conflicts with its impartiality obligations when reporting on public policy debates where the LGBT rights charity was actively campaigning.
Awaiting Government Guidance
The EHRC has been consulting on updated guidance following the Supreme Court ruling, with a consultation period that closed in June. The commission is currently considering responses and will publish a revised Code of Practice in due course, which must be submitted to the Secretary of State and laid before Parliament before coming into force.
Multiple organisations across Britain’s public and private sectors are reviewing their equality policies and training programmes to ensure compliance with the Supreme Court’s interpretation of sex-based rights under equality legislation.
The ruling has sparked intense debate about how to balance the rights of different groups under equality law, with trans rights organisations expressing concern about potential exclusion from single-sex spaces and services, whilst women’s rights campaigners argue the clarity protects sex-based rights.
Follow for more updates on Britannia Daily
Here’s the image credit for that:
Image Credit:
Photographs of flags of Israel in Hostages Square — photo by Chenspec, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0
