A man who filmed himself torturing a vulnerable 54-year-old to death whilst hurling homophobic abuse has been sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 32 years for what prosecutors called a “despicable crime”.
Matthew Jonathan, 39, of no fixed address, subjected Jamie Gawler to days of prolonged violence in the victim’s own Hereford flat, even bragging on camera that he was willing to do a lengthy prison sentence for the attack. The killer then used his victim’s bank cards to buy alcohol whilst Gawler lay dying.
Jonathan was sentenced at Worcester Crown Court on Friday after pleading guilty to murder at an earlier hearing in April. The court heard how he had filmed and photographed the brutal torture, capturing Gawler gravely injured as he directed “obscene homophobic abuse” at him.
Jamie’s brother discovered his body at the flat in Brierley Court, Hereford, on 18 January after becoming concerned for his welfare. The discovery came after a bizarre chain of events that began when the brother called Jamie’s phone, only for it to be answered by a police officer.
The officer had found the phone at Porth railway station in Wales, along with Jamie’s bank cards and those belonging to Jonathan. The killer had suffered a “medical episode” on the platform, causing the items to fall from his pockets. Jonathan was arrested the following day and charged with murder.
Mr Gawler had met Jonathan just a month before his death and, showing characteristic kindness, had offered the homeless man a place to stay in his flat. CCTV last captured Jamie alive after midnight on Sunday, 12 January, when he was seen purchasing items at a garage.
By that evening, prosecutors said, he had been subjected to a serious assault. The violence continued over several days, leaving the victim incapacitated whilst Jonathan stole and used his mobile phone and bank cards to fund alcohol purchases.
Video and photographic evidence recovered from Jonathan’s phone revealed the full horror of the attack. In one recording, he bragged about being willing to serve a lengthy prison sentence, showing what prosecutors called his “complete disregard for Jamie’s life”. Even more disturbingly, the footage showed Jamie pleading for his mother as Jonathan showed no mercy.
Kate Seal, specialist prosecutor from the Crown Prosecution Service, said: “Matthew Jonathan’s torturous mistreatment of Jamie Gawler in his own home is a despicable crime. Jonathan subjected Jamie to prolonged violence over several days.”
“At times, he left Jamie alone, seriously injured, and unable to call for help whilst he went to buy alcohol with Jamie’s money. He had the audacity to video his brutal violence and showed no mercy, even as Jamie pleaded for his mother.”
Post-mortem examination revealed Mr Gawler had suffered blunt force trauma to his head, neck and chest. The sustained nature of the attack, captured on Jonathan’s own phone, provided overwhelming evidence of his guilt.
When initially interviewed by police, Jonathan denied any involvement in Gawler’s death, claiming he had left him alive and was “distraught” to learn he had died. However, faced with the video evidence he had created himself, he later pleaded guilty to murder.
Jamie’s devastated family paid tribute to a man they described as “kind, funny and gentle”, saying their lives had been “changed forever” by his loss. In a statement read to the court, they said: “We would like to thank the West Mercia Police and prosecution team for their dedication and support in bringing this case to its conclusion.”
“The last eight months have been extremely traumatic for our family as we try, in our own way, to process the loss of Jamie, our son, brother, uncle and friend to many. Our lives have been changed forever and today has been another difficult day, having to revisit what happened, but we are glad that some justice has been achieved.”
“Jamie will be forever in our hearts and remembered as the kind, funny and gentle man that he was.”
When Jamie’s death was first announced in January, his family had described him as “a true gentleman” who was “kind, generous and funny”. The court heard how this gentle nature had led him to offer shelter to his eventual killer.
Detective Chief Inspector Gareth Lougher, who led the investigation, welcomed the sentence: “He will now serve a significant period of time in prison and whilst it will never bring Jamie back to his loved ones, hopefully it will bring some closure towards being an unimaginably difficult time for them.”
“Thankfully, Jonathan pleaded guilty to the murder and that saved his family going through and reliving the ordeal that Jamie went through in the final days of his life.”
DCI Lougher also praised his investigation team, saying: “I would also like to thank my investigation team who worked tirelessly, through some extremely difficult circumstances, to bring about today’s sentencing. The investigation involved various teams from a number of forces who all worked together to bring Jonathan to justice.”
The case highlights the vulnerability of those who offer kindness to strangers in need. Jamie Gawler’s act of compassion in offering shelter to a homeless man ultimately cost him his life in the most brutal circumstances.
Ms Seal added: “In one of the recordings, he bragged that he was willing to do a lengthy prison sentence for this offence, which showed his complete disregard for Jamie’s life. Jonathan’s actions robbed an innocent man of his life and a family of a much-loved son, brother and uncle.”
“While no-one can change the outcome of these horrific events, I hope that today’s sentence brings some justice to Jamie’s family.”
The minimum term of 32 years means Jonathan will be 71 before he can be considered for parole. Even then, he will only be released if the Parole Board determines he no longer poses a risk to the public. The life sentence means he will remain on licence for the rest of his life if ever released.
The case serves as a stark reminder of the particular vulnerability of those living alone who befriend strangers, and the importance of checking on vulnerable relatives and friends regularly. Jamie Gawler’s kindness in offering shelter to someone in need should have been met with gratitude, not the horrific violence that ended his life.
Follow for more updates on Britannia Daily
