A former prison officer has been charged with misconduct in a public office after allegedly conducting an illicit relationship with an inmate at HMP Dovegate in Staffordshire, the latest in a growing number of similar cases across UK prisons.
Sarah Barnett, 31, appeared at Derby Magistrates’ Court facing charges stemming from her time working at the Category B facility near Uttoxeter. The charges relate to alleged misconduct between 11 August and 24 August 2023.
Court documents indicate Barnett is accused of wilfully neglecting to perform her duty whilst acting as a public officer by conducting a personal relationship with a serving prisoner. She is scheduled to appear at Derby Crown Court on 6 November for her next hearing.
The case emerges as prison authorities grapple with an escalating pattern of inappropriate staff-inmate relationships. Barnett has since left the prison service and now works as a self-employed beauty therapist offering aesthetic brow and lash treatments from her home in Rugeley, Staffordshire, according to reports.
The misconduct charges carry serious consequences. Under common law, misconduct in a public office can result in a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, though sentencing varies based on the severity and circumstances of each case.
HMP Dovegate, operated by private contractor Serco since 2001, houses approximately 1,160 male prisoners aged over 21. The facility includes a unique therapeutic community offering intensive group therapy for serious repeat offenders.
In a separate but related development, another former HMP Dovegate officer pleaded guilty to similar charges. Heather Pinchbeck, 28, admitted to misconduct in a public office at Birmingham Crown Court after making illicit telephone calls to inmate Joseph Hardy, 31, between 15 February and 4 March 2023.
Hardy is serving a 14-year sentence for wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm after violently attacking an unarmed victim with a machete, resulting in the loss of the victim’s leg. The 31-year-old was convicted in 2017 for the brutal assault.
Pinchbeck received conditional bail ahead of sentencing scheduled for 9 January 2025. In September, Hardy pleaded guilty to having illicit communications with a prison officer and possessing a mobile phone in prison, receiving concurrent eight-month sentences for both offences.
The twin cases at HMP Dovegate reflect broader concerns about corruption within the UK prison system. Recent investigations have revealed increasing numbers of staff members across England and Wales facing similar charges, with female officers disproportionately represented in misconduct statistics.
Detective Chief Inspector Chris McClellan from the North West Regional Organised Crime Unit’s Prison Anti-Corruption Unit previously emphasised the severity of such breaches. Speaking about a separate case, he noted that relationships between prison staff and inmates “greatly undermines and destabilises the prison regime.”
Industry experts point to staffing challenges as a contributing factor. More than half of prison officers now have fewer than five years’ experience, compared to just 11.3% a decade ago. This rapid turnover, combined with reduced overall staff numbers despite rising prison populations, has created vulnerabilities within the system.
Former prison officer Neil Samworth, who spent 11 years at Manchester’s Strangeways, described the situation as having got “completely out of control.” He attributed the rise in inappropriate relationships to insufficient training and inexperienced staff dealing with sophisticated prisoner manipulation.
The Prison Officers’ Association has acknowledged the problem whilst defending the integrity of the vast majority of staff. Andrea Albutt, president of the association, stated that thousands of female staff “do an amazing job in very difficult circumstances on a daily basis” and warned against allowing “the odd bad apple” to detract from their service.
His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service has pledged to strengthen counter-corruption measures. The organisation is bolstering its counter-corruption unit and implementing more rigorous vetting procedures to prevent future breaches of professional conduct.
HMP Dovegate itself has faced scrutiny over recent years. An inspection report published in January 2024 identified concerns about increasing levels of violence and drug use, which inspectors noted were partly fuelled by prisoner boredom. The facility developed an action plan to address these issues.
The private prison sector, which includes HMP Dovegate, has come under particular examination. Serco currently operates five prisons across England and Wales, holding more than 4,500 individuals. The company’s contract to manage HMP Dovegate is due to expire in July 2026, with the Ministry of Justice currently running a procurement process for future operations.
Prison corruption cases involving inappropriate relationships have resulted in significant sentences. Recent convictions across the UK have seen officers receive prison terms ranging from 12 months to several years, depending on the nature and extent of their misconduct.
The Barnett case proceeds as authorities intensify efforts to root out corruption and maintain the integrity of the prison system, which relies on trust between staff, inmates, and the public.
Follow for more updates on Britannia Daily
